
For the better part of the last 20 years, the strategy behind getting your business found online has been relatively straightforward. Build a website, make sure Google understands what you do, include the right keywords, and work toward appearing as high as possible in search results. Businesses have spent billions of dollars on search engine optimization, commonly known as SEO, trying to accomplish exactly that. For local businesses, showing up when someone searched for a plumber, restaurant, attorney or insurance agency could make an enormous difference in how many customers walked through the door. But the way people search for information is changing, and businesses need to understand what that means for their websites.
Think about how you used Google five years ago. If you needed a new roof, you might search for “roofing contractors near me.” Google would return a collection of websites, advertisements, maps and business listings. You would click through several options, compare companies and hopefully find someone who could help. That process still exists, but artificial intelligence is beginning to change what happens between asking a question and finding an answer. Instead of simply providing a list of websites, search platforms are increasingly attempting to answer questions directly, summarize information and recommend options based on what someone is actually trying to accomplish.
Imagine someone searching for “What's the best roofing material for a home in Ohio that gets heavy snow?” Instead of only receiving links to roofing companies and articles, they may receive an AI-generated explanation comparing materials, costs, durability and weather considerations. They might then ask follow-up questions about installation costs, warranties or which local contractors specialize in a particular material. The experience is becoming more conversational, and the customer may gather considerable information before ever visiting a business website.
This shift is happening across multiple platforms. Google has introduced AI-powered search experiences, while tools such as ChatGPT, Microsoft's Copilot and Perplexity give consumers additional ways to research businesses, compare products and make purchasing decisions. Traditional search engines aren't disappearing, but they are no longer the only place people begin looking for answers. For business owners, that creates an important strategic question: If potential customers are getting answers from artificial intelligence, how does your business become part of those answers?
For years, many websites were built primarily around keywords. A company might create a page targeting “Bellefontaine Ohio roofing contractor” or “best insurance agency in Logan County” because those were phrases people typed into search engines. Keywords and location information still matter, but businesses increasingly need to think beyond individual search phrases. Search systems are trying to understand what a business actually does, who it serves, where it operates and whether its information is useful and trustworthy. A website that simply repeats a handful of keywords may not provide enough meaningful information to answer the questions customers are asking.
This is where I believe local businesses have an opportunity. You don't necessarily need the biggest website or the largest advertising budget to provide valuable information. You need to clearly explain your expertise. A heating and cooling company could publish helpful information about maintaining a furnace during an Ohio winter. An insurance agency could explain what homeowners should consider when reviewing coverage. A financial institution could answer common questions about financing a small business. A local restaurant could provide detailed information about its menu, dietary options, hours and services. These are the kinds of questions real customers ask, and answering them well makes your website more useful to both people and search systems.
Another important consideration is consistency. Your business information should be accurate across your website, Google Business Profile, social media accounts and other reputable online directories. If one platform lists different hours, services or contact information than another, it creates confusion. Reviews, credible mentions of your business and accurate local listings can also help establish your presence online. None of these things guarantees that an AI system will recommend your company, but they help make information about your business easier to find and evaluate.
Businesses should also reconsider what success looks like. For years, website traffic has been one of the most commonly discussed measurements of digital marketing performance. More visitors generally sounded like good news. But what happens when someone receives the information they need directly from a search result without clicking through to your website? That doesn't necessarily mean your business received no value from being discovered. It does mean website traffic alone may become a less complete picture of your online visibility. Business owners should also pay attention to phone calls, qualified inquiries, appointment requests, customer acquisition and how people say they found the company.
I also want to be careful about one misconception surrounding these changes. There isn't a magic switch that makes your website “AI-ready,” and there isn't a single deadline when traditional websites suddenly stop working. Search technology is evolving, and different platforms use different methods to find, evaluate and present information. Anyone promising guaranteed placement in AI-generated recommendations should be approached cautiously. What businesses can control is the quality, accuracy, accessibility and usefulness of the information they publish.
That brings us to a bigger issue. Many businesses have treated their website as a project rather than an ongoing part of their operation. They built it five or 10 years ago, updated the phone number occasionally and otherwise left it alone. That approach was never ideal, but the changing search environment makes it increasingly important to revisit what your website actually communicates. Does it clearly explain every major service you provide? Does it answer the questions customers commonly ask? Does it show why someone should trust your business? Is the information current? Can visitors easily contact you or take the next step?
The businesses that adapt successfully won't necessarily be the ones chasing every new technology trend. They'll be the ones that understand how their customers are changing and make thoughtful adjustments to remain relevant. That may mean improving website content, creating useful educational resources, strengthening local business listings or rethinking how online inquiries are handled. It may also mean recognizing that your website is no longer just a digital brochure. It's an important source of information that customers and automated systems may use to understand your company.
For local businesses, relationships, reputation and trust have always mattered. Artificial intelligence doesn't eliminate those advantages. In many ways, it creates new reasons to communicate them clearly. The challenge is making sure the knowledge, experience and credibility you've built in the real world are accurately represented online.
The question is no longer simply whether your business shows up on the first page of Google. It's whether customers can discover, understand and trust your business wherever they choose to search.
Question of the Week: If someone asked an AI assistant to recommend a business like yours in your community, would there be enough accurate, useful information online for it to understand why your company deserves consideration?
