
Attendees at the Indian Lake Music Boosters Holiday Market line up for homemade fare, including Mel's famous chicken and noodles. (SHARYN KOPF | THE CHRONICLE)
Funny how fast something can become SOMETHING. Take, for instance, the Indian Lake Music Boosters Holiday Market, held this past Saturday, Nov. 7.
It’s only been an annual event for eight years, but it’s quickly becoming a local tradition. And what brings in the crowds is that king of comfort food: chicken and noodles.
Though this favorite meal has been a part of the Market from the beginning, the changes made when Melanie Barnes took over four years ago have turned a good idea into a fundraising success.
Barnes started by tweaking the chicken and noodle recipe and making it her own with a secret ingredient. (And yes, I asked, but she wouldn’t tell.)
That’s when things really took off, to the point that Market organizer Colleen Kelly-Martini officially labeled them Mel’s chicken and noodles.
This is, by all available evidence, a labor of love. It took Barnes and her team 12 hours to make 16 batches filling eight large roasters. They also made mashed potatoes and green beans. It sure seemed like a lot … until they sold out less than three hours into the event.
Besides running out of her famous chicken and noodles, they also sold out of the pulled pork. But that left other items, like homemade chili and loaded nachos, to satisfy lots of appetites while raising money for the district’s music program.
And all those profits go straight to the Music Boosters.

Melanie Barnes barely slowed down during the annual Indian Lake Music Boosters Holiday Market on Saturday, Nov. 7, as she made sure the concession stand stayed stocked with food for the over 1,200 people who attended. (SHARYN KOPF | THE CHRONICLE)
“Last year we kicked in $14,000 toward band uniforms,” Mel shared. But, over the years, that’s not all. “We also put in $9,000 for choir robes. We helped with choir risers. We added another $5,000 to the bottom-line of the band trip the year they went to Hershey Park.”
For Barnes, like everyone else working the Market, it’s all about the Indian Lake School District and its music program. In fact, she served as secretary for the Boosters for five years, but considers herself semi-retired now.
Barnes grew up near Cleveland yet has lived at the Lake long enough for it to feel like home.
“It’s just my place,” she said. “I love the lake. I grew up really close to Lake Erie, so I like living right on the water. I love not being landlocked.”
Though she’ll still be helping out, Barnes is currently preparing Ashley Freeman to take over her work running concessions and the Holiday Market food stand, though they’ll still be serving Mel’s chicken and noodles. The name won’t change.
After all, she helped create a legacy.
But, even with the next Market a year away, Barnes finds herself asking an important question: how much chicken and noodles should they make next year if 16 batches weren’t enough?


