This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Riverside Lines up for a play during a 40-33 loss to New Bremen. (PRESTON SHIELDS | CHRONICLE STAFF)

A regional semifinal is never easy to win. In DeGraff, the Riverside Pirates (9-3) welcomed the New Bremen Cardinals (8-5), hoping to punch their ticket to the regional final against Marion Local. What followed was a four-quarter heavyweight fight that came down to the final 40 seconds, with the Cardinals delivering the knockout blow and the Pirates falling just short of a miracle.

The final minutes of the contest were enough to take years off the lives of both sidelines. New Bremen scored the eventual game-winning touchdown with 40 seconds remaining, and Riverside's final Hail Mary attempt fell incomplete after the Pirates worked their way into position for one last shot at extending their season.

From the opening whistle, Riverside looked like a team ready for the moment.

The Pirates' first possession set the tone. Thirteen plays, 80 yards and nearly 11 minutes came off the clock before New Bremen ever touched the football. Riverside established its physical identity early, leaning on an offensive line and rushing attack that had given opponents across Midwest Ohio fits all season.

After Riverside was stopped in the red zone, New Bremen settled for a field goal and hoped to slow the Pirates' ground game. That proved easier said than done.

Justin Mazariegos put together several significant runs to fuel the early momentum for the home team, and the Pirates continued to control the line of scrimmage.

A second Riverside possession ended with senior Dylan Trimble punching the ball into the end zone, extending the Pirates' advantage to 14-3.

New Bremen, however, had an answer.

The Cardinals quickly moved down the field, finding explosive plays through senior running back Jacob Kelly. Quarterback Gavin Dicke finished the drive with a rushing touchdown, cutting the Riverside lead to one possession.

With 41 seconds remaining before halftime, the Pirates put together another scoring drive. Trimble found the end zone for the second time, extending the lead to 20-10. Riverside missed the extra point, leaving the door open for the Cardinals.

Dicke took advantage of the opportunity, leading New Bremen down the field and connecting with his receivers to set up a field goal as time expired. The kick brought the Cardinals within one possession, sending both teams into the locker room with Riverside holding a 20-13 advantage.

Like two heavyweight boxers, every punch was met with a response.

New Bremen carried that momentum into the second half. Leaning on Kelly, the Cardinals found the end zone in the opening minute after the senior running back broke through multiple tackles and finished the drive with a touchdown. The score evened the contest at 20-20 and completely changed the complexion of the game.

Then, things got crazy.

The final 20 minutes featured just about everything a high school football fan could ask for: two missed extra points, a botched snap, a muffed onside kick and a series of momentum swings that kept both sidelines on edge.

A Riverside turnover on downs gave the Cardinals an opportunity to take their first lead of the night, and they capitalized.

Throughout the evening, head coach Bryce Hodge had continued to preach one message to his team: "Next play."

It was a reminder to move past whatever had just happened and focus on the opportunity in front of them.

The Pirates would need every bit of that mentality before the night was over.

Riverside answered with another punishing ground-game possession, capped by junior fullback Gunner Carpenter stretching across the goal line on a fourth-and-goal plunge. The touchdown put the Pirates back in front, but the extra point was unsuccessful, leaving Riverside with a narrow advantage.

Senior Drew Wilson then delivered a critical defensive play, stopping the Cardinals on third-and-short and forcing a fourth-down attempt that New Bremen could not convert.

The Pirates had another opportunity to create separation. Carpenter broke off a long run down to the two-yard line, setting up Trimble for his third touchdown of the evening. Riverside appeared poised to stretch its advantage to eight points, but the extra point sailed wide left.

That missed opportunity would loom large.

New Bremen capitalized on the opening, quickly moving down the field and finding the end zone to pull within striking distance. The Cardinals lined up for the extra point to tie the game, but a high snap disrupted the attempt. New Bremen scrambled in search of the two-point conversion, but the attempt fell short.

The Pirates held a one-point lead.

With roughly three minutes remaining, Riverside appeared to be in position to close out the game. All the Pirates needed was to recover the ensuing kickoff and put together a first down to begin draining the clock.

Instead, the onside kick was muffed.

New Bremen recovered, and suddenly the Cardinals had the football with an opportunity to steal the game.

The tension inside the stadium reached another level.

The Pirates did not flinch.

"Next play."

The Riverside defense went back to work, and for a moment, it appeared the Pirates had done enough. New Bremen faced a fourth-and-short situation outside the red zone, with the defense seemingly stopping Kelly after a minimal gain on fourth-and-2.

The spot, however, became a point of contention.

The officials discussed the placement of the football, with the two sideline officials appearing to have different marks. Despite the disagreement, the Cardinals were awarded a first down without a measurement.

New Bremen wasted little time taking advantage.

On the very next play, the Cardinals found the end zone, taking a lead with just 40 seconds remaining. The Pirates had gone from being on the doorstep of victory to facing the possibility of a season-ending defeat in a matter of moments.

Still, Riverside had one final opportunity.

"Man, what a story this is about to be," Hodge said as his team prepared for its final possession.

The Pirates moved the football down the field, fighting against the clock and giving themselves a chance to pull off one final miracle. Riverside worked its way into Hail Mary territory and had two opportunities to reach the end zone.

Neither attempt found its target.

New Bremen escaped DeGraff with a 40-33 victory, ending the Pirates' postseason run one game short of a regional championship appearance.

For Riverside, the loss does little to diminish what this team accomplished throughout the 2026 season. The Pirates battled for four quarters against a talented opponent and, for much of the evening, looked every bit like a team that belonged among the final contenders in Division VII.

The disappointment of a season-ending loss will undoubtedly linger, especially after coming so close to advancing. But there is also plenty for the community of DeGraff to celebrate.

A 9-3 season, a first-round playoff bye and two postseason victories at home are accomplishments that should not be overlooked. The Pirates gave their community something to rally behind, and the support throughout this postseason run was a reflection of what high school football means in a town like DeGraff.

More importantly, the standard has changed.

Following the loss, Hodge left his younger players with a message about what comes next and what is now expected of the program.

"Younger classmates, we will win one of these things, but it is up to you guys and how you prepare in the offseason. No matter what that looks like for you," Hodge said. "The bar is now raised for Pirates football."

The Pirates' 2026 story may have ended 40 seconds short of another opportunity, but the foundation for what comes next has already been laid.

Riverside finishes the season at 9-3, with a postseason run that raised expectations and gave the program something to build upon.

The Pirates did not get the ending they wanted. But if there is one thing this season made clear, it is that Riverside football is no longer content with simply being part of the conversation.

The bar has been raised in DeGraff. Now, the next group of Pirates has the opportunity to take it even higher.

Keep Reading