This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

The Logan County Chamber of Commerce, city officials and representatives from franchise owners, the Bajco Group, celebrate the ribbon cutting for the new Papa Johns in Bellefontaine Nov. 5. (MANDY LOEHR | THE CHRONICLE)

Signage for Papa Johns appeared a few months ago several storefronts away from Kroger in the High Point Village shopping center – and Facebook and other social media outlets were immediately abuzz with commenters wondering when the new pizza place would open.

After all, it had been many years since the popular national chain previously had a local storefront, just across the street in the Fontaine Plaza.

Thursday, Nov. 5, their wait was officially over when Papa Johns hosted its grand opening at 2129 S. Main St., Suite 110, and welcomed a long line of guests for the festivities that included giving away hundreds of free slices of pizza, along with games, prizes and a giant pizza costumed character.

“On a typical Friday night, we’ll put out 80-90 pizzas in an hour through our 450 degree oven. On a grand opening day, however, we’ll put out about 200-300 pizzas within an hour,” expert Nauman Bajwa from Bajco Group said with a grin inside the newly-opened store.

Franchise owner Nadeem Bajwa, CEO of Bajco Group, was joined in the celebration by his crew and local employees and the Logan County Chamber of Commerce for the official ribbon cutting.

Nadeem said he began working at Papa Johns as a delivery driver in 1991 when he was a student at Indiana Tech after moving to the U.S. from Pakistan. Now about 35 years later, he owns more than 270 Papa Johns locations in 12 states, all around the country, stretching as far away as Phoenix, Ariz.

“I always say I don’t run 270 restaurants, I run one restaurant 270 times,” the resident of Canfield, Ohio, near the Pennsylvania border, told the crowd. “Because in each community, we want that local team to manage and run (the restaurant).

“We cannot be successful without your support and we also know it’s our obligation to give back to the community. We’re looking forward to this partnership.”

“Logan County is a pizza community,” Logan County Chamber of Commerce President and CEO Ben Vollrath said. “You guys know this, so this is exciting to have another offering here. There’s many locations tied to this franchise and it has a great track record.

A giant slice of pizza joins in for the fun at Papa Johns’ grand opening day, where the pizza place handed out free pizza to guests lined up by a tent outside. (MANDY LOEHR | THE CHRONICLE)

“They’re one of our most recent chamber members. They went ahead and said, ‘We want to get involved right away.’ I’m really thankful for that.”

Mayor Dave Crissman and Bellefontaine City Council member Nick Davis, also representing for Senator Bernie Moreno, offered their congratulations as well.

“This is great, another business in Bellefontaine; that’s what we need, we’re growing,” Crissman said. “It’s wonderful to have this variety because everyone has different tastes in pizza. I want to thank Papa Johns for selecting Bellefontaine as their new location. This is a great day for us.”

“It’s a big boost to the local economy in Bellefontaine,” Davis said while reading from a proclamation from Senator Moreno.

The franchise owner related that he completed his triple major in management, marketing and accounting at Indiana Tech, all while working for Papa Johns, eventually moving into management roles. While he didn’t initially think that the job would turn into multiple decades of growth and success, he said he fell in love with the brand and what it stood for.

“I loved Papa Johns. Better ingredients and better pizza. I loved the brand and the people I worked with. We opened our first location in East Liverpool, Ohio, in 2002, and the rest is history.”

Nadeem is excited for his team to be involved in the Logan County community and he noted that Papa Johns has a fundraising program.

Bajco Group representatives, from the left, Nauman Bajwa, Saeed Razi, Dustin Bradley, Kyle Betts and Aaron Ailiff, join together during the grand opening celebration Nov. 5 at the new Papa Johns, 2129 S. Main St., Suite 110, Bellefontaine. (MANDY LOEHR | THE CHRONICLE)

“As we get established here, our team will be reaching out to the schools, churches and other local groups about those fundraising opportunities.

“We’re very committed to working with the community. Businesses can’t last without community support. We go hand-in-hand.”

Kae East, store manager, said she’s thrilled to step into the new role as well. She said the company promotes from within and she loves the work environment among the staff.

Papa Johns is open from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. seven days a week for carryout and delivery. The store will be closed on Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day.

Online ordering is available at www.papajohns.com or through the app, or call the restaurant at (937) 595-0395.

Keep Reading